Top 5 Restaurants You Must Try in Sarasota, According to Realtor Rich Tyson
One of the best parts of helping people move to the Suncoast is introducing them to the locals who actually make this place feel like home. Rich Tyson is one of those people. He is a second-generation Realtor who knows the Sarasota area inside and out, and when we asked him where newcomers should eat, he did not hesitate. So we are handing the mic to Rich for this one, a guided tour of the five restaurants he sends his clients and friends to again and again.
If you want the wider lay of the land first, our guide to the Sarasota food and dining scene is a great companion to this list. But if you want the shortlist from someone who lives and works here every day, this is it. Rich even filmed a visit to each spot, so you can see them for yourself.
Second-generation Realtor, Sarasota FL
GRI · LHC · RSPS · SMC · e-PRO · SFR
Originally from Rochester, New York, Rich now calls Sarasota home with his wife, daughter, and two Boston terriers. He owns a real estate brokerage back in New York, but the heart of his work is right here in the Sarasota market. With more than a decade in the business, he is a big believer in continuing education and the pursuit of excellence, and his designations show it: Graduate, REALTOR Institute (GRI), Luxury Homes Certification (LHC), Resort and Second-Home Property Specialist (RSPS), social media and digital marketing certifications (SMC and e-PRO), and Short Sales and Foreclosure Resource (SFR). He puts those digital-marketing chops to work showcasing the community on YouTube, Instagram, LinkedIn, Facebook, and TikTok. Rich keeps four words front and center in how he works: responsiveness, independence, self-motivation, and ethics. Now, on to the food.
1. Veronica Fish & Oyster
If you are in the mood to do it up a little, this is Rich's pick. Veronica Fish & Oyster is the polished end of Sarasota seafood, a downtown raw bar and dining room where the oysters are pristine, the cocktails are serious, and the room itself, all velvet booths and a marble bar, makes any night feel like an occasion. It is the kind of place Rich loves taking clients who just closed on a home and want to celebrate.
2. Owen's Fish Camp
On the other end of the spectrum, and just as beloved, is Owen's Fish Camp. Tucked into the leafy Burns Court neighborhood downtown, Owen's is Southern comfort done right: shrimp and grits, fried green tomatoes, fresh local catch, and a rustic, vine-draped fish-camp setting that feels like old Florida. Yes, there is often a wait. Rich will tell you it is worth every minute, and the laid-back garden vibe makes it easy to settle in.
3. Tommy Bahama Restaurant & Bar, St. Armands Circle
For Rich, no Sarasota food tour is complete without a stop on St. Armands Circle, and Tommy Bahama is his go-to there. The island-inspired menu, the tropical cocktails, and the people-watching from the patio capture exactly the easy, vacation-every-day feeling that makes people fall for the Suncoast in the first place. It is a perfect spot to bring out-of-town family who are still deciding whether to make the move.
4. Food & Beer
When Rich wants something more casual, Food & Beer is the answer. It is a laid-back, scratch-kitchen gastropub where the burgers, hand-cut fries, and rotating craft beer list keep regulars coming back. No pretense, just genuinely good food and a friendly local crowd. This is the kind of neighborhood spot that makes a new place start to feel like yours.
5. Cafe Amici
Rounding out the list is Cafe Amici, Rich's choice when he is craving classic Italian. Think generous pasta, wood-fired flavor, and the kind of warm, family-run hospitality that turns first-time guests into regulars. It is comfortable, consistent, and exactly the sort of dependable local favorite you want in your rotation once you have settled in.
Want Rich in your corner?
Great food is just the start of what makes the Sarasota area special, and Rich Tyson is exactly the kind of local we love introducing people to: knowledgeable, responsive, and genuinely invested in this community. If you are thinking about a move to the Suncoast and would like Rich as your agent on the ground, tell us a little about yourself below and we will personally make the introduction. No pressure, no obligation, and no cost to you.
Still deciding which part of the Suncoast fits you best? Take our 60-second community quiz first, or browse how our agent introductions work.
Disclosures. The restaurant recommendations on this page reflect the personal opinions of Rich Tyson and are shared for informational purposes only. Head to Sarasota and Rich Tyson are not affiliated with, sponsored by, or endorsed by any of the restaurants featured, and receive no compensation from them. All restaurant names, logos, and trademarks are the property of their respective owners and are used here for identification and editorial purposes only. The video tours were produced by Rich Tyson. Menus, hours, and availability change often, so please confirm details with each restaurant directly.
Rich Tyson is a licensed real estate professional serving the Sarasota, Florida area. Head to Sarasota is not a real estate brokerage; we simply introduce you to local professionals we trust. Requesting an introduction through this page is free, creates no obligation, and is not a brokerage or agency agreement. Any real estate services would be provided by Rich and his brokerage under their own terms.
Ready to find your place on the Suncoast?
Take the 60-second quiz to find your community, or talk to a local expert now.